Wednesday, March 13, 2019

Who is Beto O'Rourke, Robert O'Rourke running for President? Family, history, biography by Mary Cummins

Beto O'Rourke, Willy Nelson, Texas, vote, Democrat, El Paso, blue wave, Robert O'Rourke, Pat O'Rourke, Amy Hoover Sanders, Charlotte, Erin, Henry, Molly, Ulysses, Robert Williams, Charlotte Brooks, Melissa Williams, Pat Francis O'Rourke, mother, father, family tree, ancestry, heritage, latino, vote, voter registration, mary cummins, john francis o'rourke, mildred jasper
I originally wrote this when Beto O'Rourke was running for the Senate in Texas. Slight changes but the same biography and family history. 

Robert "Beto" Francis O'Rourke was born September 26, 1972 in El Paso, Texas. His parents are Pat Francis O'Rourke 1942-2001 and Melissa Martha Williams b. 1948. He has two younger sisters, Charlotte Jasper O'Rourke and Erin Brooks O'Rourke. Below is the pedigree view of Beto's family tree. Click it to see it larger. 

Beto O'Rourke, Robert Francis O'Rourke, Pat O'Rourke, Melissa Williams O'Rourke, Charlotte Jasper O'Rourke, Erin Brooks O'Rourke, Robert Lee Williams, Charlotte Brooks, Mildred Jasper, John Francis O'Rourke, James Francis O'Rourke, Anna Elizabeth Lloyd, Newton Jasper, O'Nora Dressler, Eunice Bird, Lewis Brooks, Marguerite Peil, El Paso, Texas, Mary Cummins, Georgia, Ireland, Irish, Wales, Senate, Texas, Democrat, blue wave, election, 2018, vote
Beto's father Pat Francis O'Rourke was a well known businessman, politician, lawyer and Judge in El Paso, Texas. From his obituary.

Robert Beto O'Rourke father Patrick Pat Francis O'Rourke, El Paso, Texas, biography  ancestry history DNA


"Political risk-taker died doing what he loved. By David Crowder, El Paso Times. Pat O'Rourke, a colorful El Paso politician, businessman and observer who lived life with passion and loved taking chances, was killed Tuesday morning riding the low-slung bicycle that was taking him across the country this time last year. A former county judge and commissioner, O'Rourke helped engineer the consolidation of the city and county tax offices and left office as the county's top Democratic official in 1986. Soon after, he switched parties to make an unsuccessful run for Congress as a Republican. He was 58; the father of one son, Robert "Beto" O'Rourke and two daughters, Charlotte and Erin; and husband to Melissa Williams O'Rourke, who runs the upscale Charlotte's furniture store on the city's West Side. Pat O'Rourke owned and managed the Ethan Allen furniture store on the West Side. A funeral Mass will be at 1 p.m. Friday at St. Patrick Cathedral, 1118 N. Mesa, after which O'Rourke will be buried at Memory Gardens of the Valley, 4900 McNutt, in Santa Teresa. Arrangements are by Martin Funeral Home West. "I just saw him two nights ago," Commissioner Dan Haggerty said. "You just kind of think that life is funny, life is fragile, and all of the things that people think are so important aren't really." Haggerty said what many others who knew O'Rourke might have thought on hearing the news that he died doing what he loved, pedaling a bicycle alone. "When he crossed the country, we followed the diary," Haggerty said, referring to the daily account O'Rourke posted on stanton-street.com, an online magazine run by his son. "He was very deep. As much as many of us would like to say we knew him, we did not know him. I think he was a lot more of a man and a lot less of a politician than some of us would like to think."

Photo of Beto's mother Melissa O'Rourke. Melissa was married to Pat in March 6, 1971 in El Paso, Texas.



Robert "Beto" O'Rourke married Amy Hoover Sanders in 2005 in Santa Fe, New Mexico. They have three children, Henry, Molly and Ulysses.

Robert Francis "Beto" O'Rourke, Amy Hoover Sanders, wedding marriage Santa Fe, New Mexico, September 24 2005, parents Pat O'Rourke, Melissa O'Rourke, William Sanders, Louann, El Paso, Texas


Beto's paternal grandparents are James Francis O'Rourke 1912 - 1966 and Mildred Rowene Jasper 1913 - 1967. From James Francis O'Rourke's obituary.

Beto O'Rourke's paternal grandfather John Francis O'Rourke El Paso Texas ancestry family history biography heritage


"O'ROURKE J. Frank O'Rourke, 54, life-lonq resident of El Paso, passed away Wednesday in Santa Fe, New Mexico where he was employed in the Public Relations Department of Reynolds Electric and Engineering Co., Inc. Survivors: wife, Mrs. Mildred O'Rourke, daughter, Mrs. Shirley Maveety, Las Cruces, New Mexico, son, Pat O'Rourke, California, brothers,. James L. O'Rourke, Garden Grove Calif., Raymond O'Rourke, El Paso. Rosary services will be held 7:30 p.m. Friday in Harding-Orr &; Mc Daniel Montana Ave. Chapel. Funeral mass will be said at 10 a.m. Saturday at St. Joseph's Catholic Church. Rt. Rev. Msgr. H. D. Buchanan officiating. Interment will be in Mt. Carmel. Pallbearers will be Donald P. Bandy, Bob Palm, R. C. Semole. Robert H. Cutler, O. D. Williams. and H. T. Etheridae."

From Mildred Jasper O'Rourke's obituary.

Mildred Rowene Jasper O'Rourke, Beto O'Rourke grandmother El Paso Texas family heritage DNA ancestry 


"O'ROURKE Mrs. Mildred J. O'Rourke, resident of Sutton Place, passed away Wednesday. She had been a resident of El Paso 29 years and was the widow of the late J. Frank O'Rourke. She was associated with Reynolds Electrical and Engineering Co.. Inc. Survivors, daughter, Mrs. Robert Maveety, Las Cruces, New Mexico; son, Pat F. O'Rourke, Los Angeles, Calif.; sisters, Mrs. Ruth Strawn, and Rita of Cimarron, Kans.; brothers, Ross Jasper, Rex Jasper, James Jasper, Fred Jasper, all of Cimarron, Kans., Beuford Jasper, Flo. 4 grandchildren. Funeral services will be held at 9 a.m. Saturday ,in the Harding-Orr &; McDaniel Montana Ave. Chapel, Rev. Konrod Kelley officiating. Interment will be in Mt. Carmel Cemetery."

Beto's maternal grandparents are Robert Lee Williams Jr. 1921 - 1976 and Charlotte Marguerite Brooks 1919 - 2003.

From Robert William's obituary.

Photo of Robert and Charlotte.

Robert Lee Williams Charlotte Brooks, Beto O'Rourke grandparents, El Paso Texas

"Robert Willliams Services Are Held. Funeral services for Robert Lee Williams Jr., who died yesterday, were to be held today at 1:30 p.m., at Harding-Orr and McDaniel Montana avenue chapel, with Rev. Ron Thomson officiating. Interment is in Mt. Carmel Cemetery, Ysleta. Mr. Williams had been president of Charlotte's Furniture Co. Inc., and had been a member of St. Clement's Episcopal Church. He had been a resident of El Paso 28 years, and lived at 1054 Torrey Pines drive. Survivors are his wife, Mrs. Charlotte B. Williams, El Paso; daughters Melissa O'Rourke, El Paso, and Patti Williams, McLean, Va.; a son, Robert Brooks Williams, El Paso; mother, Mrs. Eunice Williams, and sister, Martha Rhodes, of Picayune, Miss.; a brother, Wade Williams, New York City; grandson, Robert Francis O'Rourke. El Paso Herald, El Paso, Texas."

From Charlotte's obituary. She remarried.

"KORTH. Charlotte Williams Korth, 82, passed away Tuesday morning at her home. Charlotte Brooks was born and raised in Racine, Wisconsin and later moved to Albuquerque, New Mexico, where she met her first husband Robert L. Williams. She and Robert moved to El Paso where they raised three children and started the furniture store that bears her name. She was known nationally as a leading interior designer and Charlotte's Furniture Store is still regarded as one of the premier furniture stores in the Southwest. In 1980 she married Fred Korth, former Secretary of the U.S. Navy. She was preceded in death by her first husband, Robert L. Williams and her second husband, Fred Korth; her sister Betty Miller, her brothers, Lewis, Edward and Robert Brooks and her son- in-law Pat F O'Rourke. She is survived by her children, Patricia Williams, Melissa O'Rourke and Brooks Williams; her grandchildren, Robert F. O'Rourke, Charlotte O'Rourke Pearson, Bonnie Williams and Erin O'Rourke, and her brother-in-law Dorr Miller. Visitation will be held on Thursday, January 9, 2003 from 6 to 8 pm, with a rosary at 7 pm at Sunset Funeral Home-West located at 480 N Resler. A funeral mass will be held at 10 am, Friday, January 10, 2003 at St. Luke's Catholic Church. Interment will follow at Memory Gardens of the Valley. Donations can be mode to the El Paso Alzheimer's Association or the El Paso Museum of Art. El Paso Times, El Paso, Texas."

Beto's paternal great grandparents were James Francis O'Rourke 1879 - 1933, Anna Elizabeth Lloyd 1876 - 1963, Newton Marion Casper 1868 - 1939 and O'Nora Belle Dressler 1876 - 1965.

From James O'Rourke's obituary. He was born in Missouri.

James Francis O'Rourke, Beto O'Rourke's great grandparents family tree, ancestry heritage DNA


"O'ROURKE SERVICES SET FOR WEDNESDAY. Southern Pacific Conductor Lived in El Paso 15 Years. Funeral services for James Francis O'Rourke, 53, 1411 E. Nevada St., who died yesterday in a local hospital will be held at 9:30 a. m Wednesday in St. Patrick's cathedral. Burial will be in Evergreen. Fr. D. J. Kirgan will officiate. Rosary services will be held at 8 p. m. today in the Kaster & Maxon chapel with the Ladies of Charity in charge. Mr. O'Rourke was a Southern Pacific railroad conductor. He had lived in El Paso for the last 15 years. He is survived by his widow and three sons, James, Raymond and Frank O'Rourke, all of El Paso, and two sisters, Mrs. Frank Connolly, Enid, Okla., and Mrs. George Buck, Kansas City, Mo."

Anna Elizabeth was born 1876 in Ystradyfodwg, Glamorgan, Wales. She married James Francis in 1906 in Kansas. She died 1963 in Orange County, California.

Newton Marion Jasper was born in Clinton, Missouri 1868 and died 1939 in Las Cruces. Per the 1930's census he was a foreman at a college dairy.

O'Nora Belle Dressler was born 1876 in Randolph County, Missouri and died 1965 in Montezuma, Kansas. From her obituary.

Photo of O'Nora on the left.

Beto O'Rourke family tree ancestry heritage El Paso Texas O'Nora Belle Dressler Jasper

"Mrs. O'Nora B. Jasper. Funeral for Mrs. O'Nora B. Jasper, 88 former Garden City resident, was Saturday at the Baptist Church in Lebo. Burial was in the Lebo Cemetery. She died last Thursday at the Bethel Home in Montzuma after a lengthy illness."

Beto's maternal great grandparents were Robert Lee Williams 1888 - 1946, Eunice "Ennie" Bird 1900-1991, Lewis C Brookes 1876 - 1960 and Marguerite M Peil 1890-1927.

Robert Williams was born and died in Georgia. He was an operator at a gasoline filling station in 1940 per the census.

Eunice Bird was born in Georgia 1900 and died in Mississippi 1991. She completed four years of college. She was a supervisor for the WPA in 1940. 1958 she was the supervisor for the Housing Authority of Savannah.

Lewis Centennial Brooks was born 1876 in Ohio and died 1960 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Below is a photo of him.

Beto O'Rourke family tree, ancestry dna heritage, Lewis Centennial Brooks
From Lewis C Brook's obituary.

"Lewis Brooks, 83, Milwaukee died Sunday night in a Madison hospital. Among the survivors is a son, Lewis P., Sun Prairie. The body is at the Frautschi funeral home, 120 E. Wilson St."

"Lewis Brooks Rites. Funeral services for Lewis C Brooks, 83, Milwaukee, who died Sunday in a Madison hospital, will be held at 2 p.m. Wednesday in the Unitarian Meeting house, 900 University Bay Dr. Max D. Gaebler, minister, will officiate. Mr. Brooks was born in Lennox, Ia., and lived in Madison during the early 1940s. He was the organizer and president of the Sealshipt Oyster System until 1910. Mr. Brooks also organized and served as president of the Wisconsin National Fiber Container organization, Cudahy. He was a charter member of the University club of Milwaukee. Surviving are three sons, Lewis P., Sun Prairie; Edward H., Nashville, Tenn.; and Robert B., Cross Plains; two daughters, Mrs. James H. Carrier, Lincoln, Neb.; and Mrs. Robert L. Williams, El Paso, Tex.; and 15 -3 grandchildren. The Frautschi funeral home, 120 E. Wilson st., is in charge of arrangements."

Marguerite Peil Brooks was born 1890 in Wisconsin and died 1927 in Racine, Wisconsin. From her obituary.

"MRS. BROOKS, FORMER RACINE WOMAN, DIES. Mrs. Marguerite Brooks, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Leo A. Peil of this city, and wife of Louis C. Brooks, Milwaukee, died in that city yesterday. She is survived by her husband, five children, a sister. Mrs. Walton H. Miller, this city and a brother. Edward Piel, Chicago, and her parents. Funeral services will be held at 11 o'clock Friday morning at Holy Rosary church. Milwaukee. Burial will be in Calvary cemetery, in this city, and will be private."

I will now only do Beto's second great grandfather and wife on the O'Rourke side. Bernard "Barney" O'Rourke was born 1830 in Glencar, County Leitrim, Ireland. He died 1896 in Nebraska. Below is his obituary.

"Barney O'Rourke, well known about here, and who owned a farm northeast of town, but who lived near Nebraska City, was last week returning from that city to his home, with another person, in a buggy, when, by the horses taking fright, or some other accident, they were thrown out. O'Rourke's collar-bone was broken, but it was thought that he was not otherwise hurt. However, he was undoubtedly injured internally, as he suddenly became worse, Friday, and died that evening. When the Rock Island road was being built through here, he operated a boarding car."

An article from 1892 about him.

"Bernard O'Rourke a former old and respected citizen of St. Joseph, but now of Talmage, Nebraska, made a very pleasant call at the Tribune office Wednesday on his way home from the Indian Nation, where he has been engaged all spring in the construction of a railroad. Mr. O'Rourke built and ran the Everett house on South Seventh street many years ago and looks as fresh today as he did then."

Barney's wife was Mary Anne McDermott born in Ohio 1848 and died in El Paso in 1923. From her obituaries.

"MRS. MARY A. O'ROURKE DIES WHILE VISITING HER SONS. Mary A. O’Rourke, 74 years old mother of J. F. and H. J. O’Rourke of El Paso, died Saturday at 1411 East Nevada Street. Mrs. O’Rourke arrived in El Paso last Monday from her home in Herington, Kan., for a visit with her sons. Besides her sons here, she is survived by two daughters in Herington, Mrs. Frank Connolly and Miss Alice O’­ Rourke; a son, B. J. O'Rourke, of Parsons. Kan., and a brother, P. J. McDermott of Liberal, Kansas. The body will be forwarded tonight to Harrington for burial by the J. J. Kaster & company."

"Mrs. Mary A. O'Rourke Dead. Mrs. O'Rourke is dead. This simple message, which passed from neighbor to neighbor and on through the town Saturday, brought a shade of sadness to the hearts of all who heard it, for this good woman who has lived among us for a number of years, had endeared herself to all by her simple kindnessm her consistent christian life, her charming personality and her cheeriness at all times. The children loved her, the young people enjoyed her the older friends trusted her and came for sympathy and understanding and her immediate family and friends adored her. Her passing leaves a place that cannot be filled, but her life among us leaves a pleasant memory of kindly service and unselfish devotion to family, friends and her religion, that is an inspiration to all and  will linger long after she has gone.  Mrs. O'Rourke left Herington about ten days ago to visit her brother at Liberal and two sons at El Paso, Texas, and was taken ill with pneumonia the second day of her visit there. Her daughter, Miss Alice went to her, arriving the day before her death and everything possible was done to save her for her family and friends but death claimed her on Saturday morning at eight forty-five. The body arrived in Herington Monday morning accompanied by her daughter and her two sons, H. J. and J. F. O'Rourke and their wives. The older son B. J. O'Rourke of Parsons and his son, Bernard, arrived Sunday afternoon, also Mrs. C. G. Stevenson of Pratt, Kansas, a niece. The brother, T. J. McDermott of Liberal. Kansas, was prevented from coming by sudden illness. Mrs. O'Rourke has made her home with her daughter, Mrs. F. P. Connolly for over five years and the funeral was from this home to St. John's Catholic church where a High Requiem mass was said with Father J. B. Glynn officiating. Prayers for the repose of her soul were offered by the ladies of the Altar society and the Knights of Columbus at the home Monday afternoon and evening. Interment was made at St. John's cemetery. Out of town relatives and friends were Mr. and Mrs. J. F. O'Rourke and Mr. and Mrs. H. J. O'Rourke of El Paso, Texas; B. J. and Bernard O'Rourk of Parsons, Kansas; Mr. and Mrs. C. G. Stevenson of Pratt, Kansas; Mr. and Mrs. J. C. Cole of Dalhart, Texas; Mrs. Jas. Gleason and Mr. and Mrs. J. P. McSteen of Kansas City, Missouri and Mrs. John Crowley of Pratt, Kansas. Mary Ann McDermott was born near Cleveland, Ohio, August 20th, 1848 and died at El Paso, Texas, January 27, 1923. She was married to Bernard O'Rourke at St. Joseph's cathedral, St. Joseph, Missouri, August 26, 1866. Nine children were born of this union, three of whom died in infancy and one son, Domino, died May 4, 1807, being killed while in railroad service. Mr. O'Rourke died at Talmage, Nebraska, August 26, 1896. The O'Rourke's lived at St. Joseph, Missouri, for many years coming west with the Rock Island Railroad as it built from that place. Mrs. O'Rourke leaves the following children: -  B. J. of Parsons, Kansas; ,J. F. and H. J. of El Paso, Texas; Miss. Alice and Mrs. F. P. Connolly of Herington, besides a brother, T. J. McDermott of Liberal, Kansas, and twelve grand children." Transcribed by Mary Cummins.

I may later post the maternal second great grandparents. For now the paternal side of the family is from Ireland, Wales, Kentucky, Missouri and Kansas. The maternal side of the family is from Georgia, Massachusetts, Canada and Wisconsin. The family history matches up perfectly with what Beto O'Rourke has said about his family tree. I've done the family trees and histories of other candidates and Beto is the only one who has been honest about his family history. Beto is a third generation Texan from El Paso.

Beto's wife Amy Hoover Sanders comes from an amazing family. They lived in Mexico and Texas. My family is from El Paso, Texas which is on the Mexican border. That's how my grandpa met my Nana. It was normal to go back and forth frequently over the border. Below is Amy's tree only to great grandparents. Amy's family is highly educated, successful and wealthy. They've been in Texas and Mexico for generations. One was a well known Texas Judge. They are from Germany and the US. They're also involved in a lot of philanthropy.

Amy Hoover Sanders, family tree, ancestry, heritage, Texas, Mexico, Germany

Someone wrote an article about my article. Very cool.

https://www.irishcentral.com/news/politics/irish-roots-beto-o-rourke

Mary Cummins of Animal Advocates is a wildlife rehabilitator licensed by the California Department of Fish and Game. Mary Cummins is also a licensed real estate appraiser in Los Angeles, California.

Mary Cummins, Mary K. Cummins, Mary Katherine Cummins, Mary Cummins-Cobb, Mary, Cummins, Cobb, real estate, appraiser, appraisal, instructor, teacher, Los Angeles, Santa Monica, Beverly Hills, Pasadena, Brentwood, Bel Air, California, licensed, permitted, single family, condo, pud, hud, fannie mae, freddie mac, uspap, certified, residential, certified resident, apartment building, multi-family, commercial, industrial, expert witness, civil, criminal, orea, dre, insurance, bonded, experienced, bilingual, spanish, english, form, 1004, 2055, land, raw, acreage, vacant, insurance, cost, income approach, market analysis, comparative, theory, appraisal theory, cost approach, sales, matched pairs, plot, plat, map, diagram, photo, photographs, photography, rear, front, street, subject, comparable, sold, listed, active, pending, expired, cancelled, listing, mls, multiple listing service, claw, themls,

Monday, March 11, 2019

Who is Jeanine Ferris Pirro of Fox News? Immigrant from Syria. Judge Jeanine, by Mary Cummins

Jeanine Ferris, Jeanine Pirro, Judge Jeanine, @JudgeJeanine, Fox News, hijab, head covering, catholic, albert pirro, prison, divorced, immigrant, syria, albert pirro, nasser ferris, calal joseph, awad, esther awad, juliette shaheen, new york, dna, ancestry, syrian, family tree, heritage, 


UPDATE: 04/04/2019 Possible corrections. A relative of Jeanine sent in some corrections.

Jeanine's birth date may be 1951. The 1946 birth date I listed may be the birth date of her sister. Jeanine listed her birth date as 1946 in two directories. There is no birth certificate available.

Jeanine's mother  Esther's birth date may be 1924. Her headstone shows a birth date of 1927. Esther listed her birth date as 1928.

Jeanine's maternal grandmother Julie Shaheen may have been born in New York or Lebanon and not Iran. The census lists her birth in Syria. California death certificate states "other country."

If I find documents to support any of these items, I will add them to this blog. Thanks for the tips!

03/16/2019 Jeanine Pirro's show episode was pulled tonight. Don't know if it's permanent. The show lost three advertisers because of Jeanine's racist comments last week.

https://www.adweek.com/tvnewser/jeanine-pirros-show-wont-air-on-fox-news-tonight-a-week-after-her-controversial-rep-omar-remarks/396918

ORIGINAL: Jeanine Ferris Pirro was born September 1, 1946 in Elmira, New York. Her father was Nasser Leo Ferris Jr 1923 - 1978. Below is his obituary.

FERRIS, Mr. Nasser Leo, Age 54 of 828 West Second St., Friday, July 14, 1978 after a prolonged illness. Friends are invited to call at the Hughes & Sons Funeral Home. Prayer service at the funeral home Monday at 9:30 a.m. followed by a Funeral Mass of Christian Burial in Our Lady of Lourdes Church at 10 a.m. Burial in Sts. Peter & Paul Cemetery. He is survived by his wife, Mrs. Esther (Awad) Ferris; daughters, Mrs. Mary Louise Rusin of Seattle, Wash, and Atty. Jeanine Ferris-Pirro of Harrison, NY.; father, F. M. Ferris of Binghamton, N. Y. half-brother, Fred Joseph of Scranton, Pa. He was a communicant of Our Lady of Lourdes Church; a U.S. Navy veteran of W W II having served in the Pacific and Philippine Island Theatres of Operation. He was the Manager of Chemung County Transit System; former owner of Charlie's Cafe in Scranton, Pa.; part owner of the High Park Hotel in Scranton; a member of the Elmira Heights American Legion; and former manager of the C. Awad Mobile Homes. Star-Gazette, 15 Jul 1978. Transcription by Mary Cummins.

Jeanine Pirro's mother is Esther M Awad Joseph born 1928 in New York. Here is a pic of Esther and Nasser.

Jeanine Ferris, Jeanine Pirro, Judge Jeanine, @JudgeJeanine, Fox News, hijab, head covering, catholic, albert pirro, prison, divorced, immigrant, syria, albert pirro, nasser ferris, calal joseph, awad, esther awad, juliette shaheen, new york, dna, ancestry, syrian, family tree, heritage, 

Jeanine has a younger sister, Mary Louise Ferris-Rusin born 1951.

Jeanine graduated from private Catholic school Notre Dame High School. This photo is from 1968.

Jeanine Ferris, Jeanine Pirro, Judge Jeanine, @JudgeJeanine, Fox News, hijab, head covering, catholic, albert pirro, prison, divorced, immigrant, syria, albert pirro, nasser ferris, calal joseph, awad, esther awad, juliette shaheen, new york, dna, ancestry, syrian, family tree, heritage, 

Jeanine graduated from the University of Buffalo in New York in 1972 and Albany Law School. She became an Assistant Deputy Attorney.

August 23, 1975 Jeanine Ferris married Albert James Pirro Jr. a lawyer at Our Lady of Lourdes Church, Elmira. His grandparents are from Italy. Together they have two children Christine b. 1986 and Alexander b. 1989. Albert "Al" Pirro was Donald Trump's highest paid lobbyist in the '80's and '90's helping him lobby for casinos and real estate.

"On February 23, 1999, Pirro's husband was indicted by the office of United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York on one count of conspiracy, four counts of tax evasion, and 28 counts of filing a false tax return for hiding over $1 million in personal income as business expenses between 1988 and 1997.That day, Pirro appeared with her husband at a joint press conference in response to the charges, criticizing the investigation as "invasive and hostile." New York Governor George Pataki released a statement saying that the Pirros had been personal friends for "a long time" and that he and his wife "wished them well." With the trial beginning on May 15, 2000, and closing arguments given on June 19, 2000, the jury found Pirro's husband guilty on June 23, 2000 on 23 of the charges brought against him and not guilty of 10.In November 2000, he was sentenced to 29 months in a minimum security federal prison but received some leniency in exchange for waiving his right to appeal. In the midst of the trial, Pirro had attacked the prosecution for bringing up matters which involved her, calling it a "desperate attempt by them to bring me into this wherever they can. The couple separated in 2007 with their divorce being finalized in 2013."

After Jeanine's husband's arrest her political career was negatively affected. She blames all of her political failures on other people. She even blames her husband being arrested and charged with tax evasion on other people. Everything negative that happens in her life she has blamed on others.

While she was the District Attorney there were some questionable charges and lack of charges against certain wealthy well known individuals. Jeanine ran for Senate against Hillary Clinton but dropped out to run for Attorney General. Jeanine lost that election to Andrew Cuomo.

Albert's brother Anthony G. Pirro an accountant did Albert's tax returns. Anthony was also charged and sent to prison. Albert was so low that he blamed his tax return mistakes on his brother whom he tried to frame. Albert also claimed his brother was a cocaine addict. In turn Anthony claimed Al was admitted to a psych ward for depression and mood swings.

Al cheated on his wife and fathered another daughter with another woman. There was a paternity case. He was the father and paid child support.

Jeanine Ferris Pirro's paternal grandfather was Ferris Nasser Nathan Ferris 1895-1980 born in Beirut, Lebanon. Below is his obituary,

"Ferris N.Ferris of Binghamton. Ferris N. Ferris, age 84, of 140 Laurel Ave., died Monday at Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital. He is survived by his wife, Mrs. Nora Hamdan Ferris, Binghamton; 2 grandchildren, Mary Louise Ferris, Jenine Ferris Pirro; 2 step sons, Fred Joseph of Scranton and Fred A. Hamden of Endicott; several cousins. Mr. Ferris was a member of St. Thomas Aquinas Church. Funeral services at 9 a.m. Wednesday at the Ernest H. Parsons Funeral Home, Inc., 71 Main St., Binghamton, and 9:30 a.m. at St. Thomas Aquinas Church where a Mass of Christian Burial will be offered. The family will receive friends at the funeral home, Tuesday 3:30 until 5:30 and 7-9 p.m. Burial in Floral Park Cemetery. Press and Sun-Bulletin, Binghamton, New York, Dec. 23, 1980. Transcription by Mary Cummins."

Jeanine Pirro's paternal grandmother was Rose Halabi/Halebe born 1895 in Lebanon, Syria died 1945 Scranton, Pennsylvania. Grandparents were divorced. It was contentious.

Jeanine Pirro's maternal grandfather was Calal/Caleb Charles Merod Joseph Awad Sr 1908-1961. His original last name coming to the US was Joseph. He later changed it to Awad. Below are his obituaries and a write up by me.

CHARLES M. AWAD. Awad, Real Estate Broker, Dies. Charles M. Awad Sr. of 3079 Arnold Ave., Horseheads; a prominent Horseheads business man, died at the Arnot-Ogden Hospital at 8:15 this morning following an extended illness. He was 53. Mr. Awad was a real estate broker and owned the Awad Trailer Sales Inc. of 3026 Grand Central Ave., Horseheads. A native of the Republic of Lebanon, he came to this country while still a boy and settled with his parents in Cortland in 1917. He was graduated from Cortland schools and attended Elmira College for two years. He entered the U. S. Navy in 1942 and saw action during WWII. He was injured in the battle of Salerno and was taken to the Jacksonville, Fla., naval hospital. He operated a Newburgh, N. Y., restaurant and a Scranton Supermarket before moving here in 1947. From 1947 to 1950, he was active in Athletic Promoters Inc., a group which sponsored athletic events in the area. In 1950 he returned to Lebanon for a year's visit. He then entered the real estate business here, and later established the trailer sales. Mr. Awad was married to the former Miss Ruth Bullis of New Haven, Conn., in 1944. A member of Harry B. Bentley American Legion Post at Elmira, Mr. Awad also belonged to the American Lebanese Federation of the Eastern Coast and the Elmira Heights and Horseheads auxiliary police organizations. During the past 10 years, he has visited Europe on several occasions. He has been active in several local drives to raise funds for St. Mary's Church, Baslim, Lebanon. For the past seven years, Mr. Awad delivered baskets of food to needy families on Christmas Eve. He was a communicant of St. Charles Borremeo Church, Elmira Heights. Star-Gazette, Elmira, New York. Transcription by Mary Cummins.

Charles M. Awad Sr. of 3079 Arnold Ave., Horseheads, Tuesday, May 16, 1961. He was a real estate broker and a communicant of St. Charles Borromeo Church, Elmira Heights. Survived by wife, Mrs. Ruth E. Awad; daughters, Mrs. Leo Ferris of Elmira, Mrs. Alex Mezhur of Lebanon, Mrs. Michael Shahin of Boston, Mrs. Donald Charles of San Francisco; sons, Charles M. Jr., and Joseph C. at home; sisters, Mrs. Joseph Abdou of Cortland; mother, Mrs. Helen Awad of Lebanon; brother, Joseph of Lebanon; 10 grandchildren. Body at Hughes Funeral Home. Calling hours: today 2 to 4 and 7 to 10 p.m., Thursday 3 to 5 and 7 to 10 p.m. Prayer service there Friday at 8:15 a.m.. Solemn Requiem High Mass at 9 in St. Charles Borromeo Church. Elmira Heights. St. Peter & Paul's Cemetery. Transcription by Mary Cummins.

His original name was Calale/Caleb Merod Joseph. His parents were Merod Joseph and Helen Hakeel both born in Lebanon. His first wife was Juliette/Julia Marie Shaheen 1911-1984. She and Calale Merod Joseph are the parents of Esther, Edna, Jennie and Nellie Joseph. They were married October 6, 1926 in Niagara Falls. 1928 Charles was involved in a car accident while driving his bakery delivery truck. He was burned and injured in the accident. In 1929 he filed for bankruptcy. Charles abandoned his family in 1936. Juliette filed for divorce due to "non support and extreme cruelty." Divorce was granted 1937 in Bay County, Michigan. Charles changed his name before 1940 to Awad. He remarried and had two sons. His daughter Esther told the Times that the father divorced her mother as she only bore him daughters and he wanted sons. He is the grandfather of Jeanine Ferris Pirro.

Here's a photo of him.

Jeanine Ferris, Jeanine Pirro, Judge Jeanine, @JudgeJeanine, Fox News, hijab, head covering, catholic, albert pirro, prison, divorced, immigrant, syria, albert pirro, nasser ferris, calal joseph, awad, esther awad, juliette shaheen, new york, dna, ancestry, syrian, family tree, heritage, 
Jeanine Pirro's maternal grandmother is Juliette "Julie" Shaheen Wainwright born 1911 in Kuzestan,  Iran, died 1984 in San Francisco, CA.

Her obituary,

"WAINWRIGHT, Juliette. In So SF, Sept. II, 1984; beloved mother of Esther Ferris, Edna Mezher, Jeanine Shahin and Najala Charles; dear sister of William Shaneen, Jeannie Batrouny, Sylvia Haick, Nellie Elias, Ethel and the late Helen Anthony; also survived by many grandchildren and great-grandchildren. Friends may call after 3 p.m. Wed. and are invited to attend services Fri. at 1 p.m. at DUGGAN'S SERRA MORTUARY, 500 Westlake Ave. DC. Interment Olivet Cem. Transcription by Mary Cummins." Juliette's parents were Abraham Shaheen June 14, 1878 - Oct 13, 1964 and Shafika Fadel 1888 - June 7, 1922.

Jeanine Pirro's paternal great grandparents were Nathan Ferris 1872-1927 born in Turkey,  Libbie/Libby Schere 1879 - 1947 born in Syria.

Jeanine Pirro's maternal great grandparents were Merod Joseph 1877 - 1931 born in Syria, Helen Hakeel 1881-1961 born in Syria, Abraham Shaheen 1878-1964 born in Lebanon and Shaafika Fadel 1888 - 1922 born in Lebanon, Syria.

Based on this research Jeanine Ferris Pirro is 100% Syrian. Her kids are 50% Syrian and 50% Italian. Her family came here poor from Syria and worked hard to attain the American Dream. Now that Jeanine is in the country she doesn't want any other immigrants to enter. She's an immigrant hating immigrant.

Another thing to note is that Jeanine wore a religious head covering in church and Catholic school. Here she is wearing her religious head covering just outside of church. Why is she against Iilan Omar wearing religious head covering? Jeanine claims Omar is a Muslim and her religion comes before the Constitution. That is incorrect but what is true is Jeanine is a Catholic. God, the bible and the Pope come before the law or Constitution. That's why some didn't want to let Irish Catholics in the US. They didn't think they'd follow the law or the Constitution. That didn't happen.

Jeanine Ferris, Jeanine Pirro, Judge Jeanine, @JudgeJeanine, Fox News, hijab, head covering, catholic, albert pirro, prison, divorced, immigrant, syria, albert pirro, nasser ferris, calal joseph, awad, esther awad, juliette shaheen, new york, dna, ancestry, syrian, family tree, heritage, 

I've actually communicated with a couple of Jeanine's relatives. They are nice down to earth people. I don't believe Jeanine is reflective of her entire family. She appears to be an overly driven Type A personality who loves to attack people like immigrants and Muslims. What's odd is that her grandparents helped immigrants. She's like a Stephen Miller but for Syrians instead of Jews.

* This information comes from public documents and newspapers.com

Mary Cummins of Animal Advocates is a wildlife rehabilitator licensed by the California Department of Fish and Game. Mary Cummins is also a licensed real estate appraiser in Los Angeles, California.

Mary Cummins, Mary K. Cummins, Mary Katherine Cummins, Mary Cummins-Cobb, Mary, Cummins, Cobb, real estate, appraiser, appraisal, instructor, teacher, Los Angeles, Santa Monica, Beverly Hills, Pasadena, Brentwood, Bel Air, California, licensed, permitted, single family, condo, pud, hud, fannie mae, freddie mac, uspap, certified, residential, certified resident, apartment building, multi-family, commercial, industrial, expert witness, civil, criminal, orea, dre, insurance, bonded, experienced, bilingual, spanish, english, form, 1004, 2055, land, raw, acreage, vacant, insurance, cost, income approach, market analysis, comparative, theory, appraisal theory, cost approach, sales, matched pairs, plot, plat, map, diagram, photo, photographs, photography, rear, front, street, subject, comparable, sold, listed, active, pending, expired, cancelled, listing, mls, multiple listing service, claw, themls,

Tuesday, February 26, 2019

Who is James Suthann who broke off the tail of a service dog in Brevard County, Florida? Long criminal history

james suthann, james corell doughty suthann, 37 animal cruelty, dog, tail, service dog, brevard county, florida, groomer, arrested, mugshot, booking photo, jail, sheriff, mary cummins, felony, bail, trial, groomer

BREAKING STORY. CHECK BACK FOR UPDATES.

06/26/2019 09:00 AM CAL:DOCKET SOUNDING MOORE JUSTICE CENTER MORGAN LAUR REINMAN mcl98

Next court appearance is 04/17/2019 for docket sounding.

03/13/2019 Assistant State Attorney Anthony Mechachonis Bar No 124230 officially charged Suthann for Cruelty to Animals, death, pain or suffering (F3) 828.12(2) felony in the third degree March 12, 2019. The case uber is 052019CF017567AXXXXX. Next court hearing is April 17, 2019 900 a.m. Moore Justice Center Judge Morgan Laur Reinman. Below is the charging document.



He is currently living in Satellite Beach, FL 32937. There are 22 criminal cases against him in Brevard County, Florida alone from 1998 to 2019. Court search is messed up. I can only find the current case by only searching his last name. I think they strung his first and two middle names together. Drivers license # is S350443812880 which is what I searched.

Below is the search results.

DEFENDANT 1 05-1998-TR-045483-AXXX-XX 03/30/1998 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-1998-TR-046819-AXXX-XX 11/03/1998 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-1999-IN-045693-AXXX-XX 11/05/1999 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-1999-MM-047683-AXXX-XX 11/09/1999 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2000-MM-038461-AXXX-XX 06/01/2000 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2001-MM-046352-AXXX-XX 06/06/2001 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2002-TR-030878-AXXX-XX 05/07/2002 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2004-TR-098389-AXXX-XX 12/28/2004 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2006-TR-023928-AXXX-XX 03/14/2006 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2006-TR-072295-AXXX-XX 08/29/2006 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2011-IN-001423-AXXX-XX 06/01/2011 SUTHANN JAMES CORRELLD 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2011-TR-057341-AXXX-XX 10/26/2011 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2012-MM-034214-AXXX-XX 02/06/2012 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2012-TR-031509-AXXX-XX 05/25/2012 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2013-MM-053303-AXXX-XX 01/15/2013 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
RESPONDENT 1 05-2014-DR-019917-XXXX-XX 03/24/2014 SUTHANN JAMES CORELL 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2014-CF-028268-AXXX-XX 05/28/2014 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2014-CF-033932-AXXX-XX 07/10/2014 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2014-CF-037256-AXXX-XX 08/07/2014 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2015-CO-022096-AXXX-XX 04/06/2015 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2015-CF-028093-AXXX-XX 05/26/2015 SUTHANN JAMES C 08/08/1981 0.00
DEFENDANT 1 05-2019-CF-017567-AXXX-XX 02/25/2019 SUTHANN JAMES CORELL DOUGHTY 08/08/1981 0.00


Photo of the incident right before the tail is broken off.



Interview with the dog owner.



James Suthann, James Corell Doughty Suthann was arrested for felony animal cruelty. He was grooming a service dog for a disabled veteran suffering from PTSD. He didn't feel the dog was standing still enough so he twisted his tail 360 degrees breaking it off. Tail was removed. Police refuse to release video of incident as it is too graphic.

James has been arrested six times in Brevard County, Florida alone since 2012. The charges are aggravated stalking and two arrests for violation of domestic protective order. Also arrested for criminal mischief in a religious building, see all below. He was awaiting trial on all of them with no sentencing since 2012? Could they not find him? He's had the same home address for years. They should have arrested his violent ass before this happened. Grooming salon needs to do a basic background check. I did a quick free check in less than a minute.

He was injured in a motorcycle crash in 2011 when he ran into a car. Father is Robert, mother is Dannelle. His first name is from his paternal grandfather. His middle names are from his maternal grandfather.



More booking photos.

james suthann, james corell doughty suthann, 37 animal cruelty, dog, tail, service dog, brevard county, florida, groomer, arrested, mugshot, booking photo, jail, sheriff, mary cummins, felony, bail, trial, groomer

james suthann, james corell doughty suthann, 37 animal cruelty, dog, tail, service dog, brevard county, florida, groomer, arrested, mugshot, booking photo, jail, sheriff, mary cummins, felony, bail, trial, groomer

james suthann, james corell doughty suthann, 37 animal cruelty, dog, tail, service dog, brevard county, florida, groomer, arrested, mugshot, booking photo, jail, sheriff, mary cummins, felony, bail, trial, groomer

james suthann, james corell doughty suthann, 37 animal cruelty, dog, tail, service dog, brevard county, florida, groomer, arrested, mugshot, booking photo, jail, sheriff, mary cummins, felony, bail, trial, groomer
james suthann, james corell doughty suthann, 37 animal cruelty, dog, tail, service dog, brevard county, florida, groomer, arrested, mugshot, booking photo, jail, sheriff, mary cummins, felony, bail, trial, groomer

I believe this is his sister.
james suthann, james corell doughty suthann, 37 animal cruelty, dog, tail, service dog, brevard county, florida, groomer, arrested, mugshot, booking photo, jail, sheriff, mary cummins, felony, bail, trial, groomer

His family is from Maryland, Ohio and New Jersey. His sister above was a beauty queen who lost control of her car, rolled it, didn't wear a seat belt and died instantly.

james suthann, james corell doughty suthann, 37 animal cruelty, dog, tail, service dog, brevard county, florida, groomer, arrested, mugshot, booking photo, jail, sheriff, mary cummins, felony, bail, trial, groomer, family tree, ancestry, dna, heritage

Here is a more detailed rap sheet. They updated the system since he was arrested. He was found guilty of some of the past charges. There are a lot more charges.

1999 non-criminal boating, driving without lights.
1999 having, smoking pot, guilty
2000 drinking under age, drugs, guilty.
2001 drinking under age, failure to appear, guilty.
Lots of traffic tickets.
2016 guilty of stalking
2014 more stalking charges. He dated a woman for 1.5 years. She ended it and he kept following, calling, messaging her. She got a restraining order and he violated it many times. James stated he was indigent. He got 12 months of probation. He must have psychiatric treatment. He can't have weapons. He must stay away from woman. He must take substance abuse treatment. He took a plea agreement.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/18fCqmYuBajuaM1-dpfyIKWFL7csGpecX/view?usp=sharing



Below are his most recent arrests in only Brevard County, Florida.
Inmate Details - Suthann, James Corell Doughty
Demographic Information
Name:
Suthann, James Corell Doughty
Subject Number:
326064
Date of Birth:
08/08/1981
Age:
37
Gender:
Male
Race:
White
Height:
68
Weight:
190.0
Address
339 IBIS LN
Satellite Beach, FLORIDA 32937

02/25/2019 14:05

02/25/2019 14:05
Booking History Click Here for Custody Status Updates
Booking 2019-00002978
Booking Date:02/25/2019 12:56
Release Date:02/25/2019 22:23:26
Prisoner Type:03 - FAM Awaiting Trial
Total Bond Amount:
Total Bail Amount:
Booking Origin:
Bond Number Bond Type Bond Amount Charge Count
2019-00006946 Cash or Surety $2,000.00 1
Charge Offense Date Docket Number Sentence Length Crime Class Court Date Judge Arresting Agency Attempt/Commit
Animal Cruelty-Felony-Cause Cruel Death Pain & Suffering 02/25/2019 Felony 02/26/2019 Initial Appearance Brevard County Sheriff's Office Committed


Booking 2015-00005534
Booking Date:05/25/2015 21:38
Release Date:06/29/2015 17:09:34
Prisoner Type:03 - FAM Awaiting Trial
Total Bond Amount:$0.00
Total Bail Amount:
Booking Origin:
Bond Number Bond Type Bond Amount Charge Count
2015-00013386 Release on Recognizance $0.00 1
2015-00013387 Release on Recognizance $0.00 1
Charge Offense Date Docket Number Sentence Length Crime Class Court Date Judge Arresting Agency Attempt/Commit
Booking 2014-32606403
Booking Date:05/28/2014 07:47
Release Date:05/30/2014 23:14:00
Prisoner Type:03 - FAM Awaiting Trial
Total Bond Amount:
Total Bail Amount:
Booking Origin:
Bond Number Bond Type Bond Amount Charge Count
2014-90418438 Cash or Surety $5,000.00 1
2014-90418439 Co-Signature $1,000.00 1
Charge Offense Date Docket Number Sentence Length Crime Class Court Date Judge Arresting Agency Attempt/Commit
Agg Stalking 05/28/2014 14CF028268A Felony 07/01/2014 Wohn, Robert Jr Brevard County Sheriff's Office Data Conversion
Viol Injunction Protection Domestic Viol 05/28/2014 14CF028268A Misdemeanor 07/01/2014 Wohn, Robert Jr Brevard County Sheriff's Office Data Conversion
Booking 2014-32606401
Booking Date:08/06/2014 14:02
Release Date:08/29/2014 22:03:00
Prisoner Type:03 - FAM Awaiting Trial
Total Bond Amount:
Total Bail Amount:
Booking Origin:
Bond Number Bond Type Bond Amount Charge Count
Charge Offense Date Docket Number Sentence Length Crime Class Court Date Judge Arresting Agency Attempt/Commit
Booking 2014-32606400
Booking Date:07/10/2014 14:26
Release Date:07/11/2014 22:24:00
Prisoner Type:08 - MAM Awaiting Trial
Total Bond Amount:
Total Bail Amount:
Booking Origin:
Bond Number Bond Type Bond Amount Charge Count
2014-90418429 Cash or Surety $5,000.00 1
2014-90418430 Not Applicable $0.00 1
Charge Offense Date Docket Number Sentence Length Crime Class Court Date Judge Arresting Agency Attempt/Commit
Agg Stalking 07/10/2014 14CF033932A Felony 08/12/2014 Crawford, Charlie Brevard County Sheriff's Office Data Conversion
Viol Injunction Protection Domestic Viol 07/10/2014 14CF033932A Misdemeanor 08/12/2014 Crawford, Charlie Brevard County Sheriff's Office Data Conversion
Booking 2012-32606402
Booking Date:02/06/2012 19:38
Release Date:02/08/2012 00:57:00
Prisoner Type:08 - MAM Awaiting Trial
Total Bond Amount:
Total Bail Amount:
Booking Origin:
Bond Number Bond Type Bond Amount Charge Count
2012-90418437 Not Applicable $0.00 1
Charge Offense Date Docket Number Sentence Length Crime Class Court Date Judge Arresting Agency Attempt/Commit
Criminal Mischief Religious Building 02/06/2012 12MM034214A Felony 03/01/2012 Koons, Stephen Satellite Beach Police Department Data Conversion

Mary Cummins of Animal Advocates is a wildlife rehabilitator licensed by the California Department of Fish and Game. Mary Cummins is also a licensed real estate appraiser in Los Angeles, California.

Mary Cummins, Mary K. Cummins, Mary Katherine Cummins, Mary Cummins-Cobb, Mary, Cummins, Cobb, real estate, appraiser, appraisal, instructor, teacher, Los Angeles, Santa Monica, Beverly Hills, Pasadena, Brentwood, Bel Air, California, licensed, permitted, single family, condo, pud, hud, fannie mae, freddie mac, uspap, certified, residential, certified resident, apartment building, multi-family, commercial, industrial, expert witness, civil, criminal, orea, dre, insurance, bonded, experienced, bilingual, spanish, english, form, 1004, 2055, land, raw, acreage, vacant, insurance, cost, income approach, market analysis, comparative, theory, appraisal theory, cost approach, sales, matched pairs, plot, plat, map, diagram, photo, photographs, photography, rear, front, street, subject, comparable, sold, listed, active, pending, expired, cancelled, listing, mls, multiple listing service, claw, themls,

Sunday, February 24, 2019

Oscar winner best film for "Green Book" is a fraud. Dr Donald Shirley did not want a book or movie made

green book, screen play, dr donald shirley, movie, oscar, award, best picture, fraud, nick vallelonga, tony vallelonga, fiction, fraud, lies, mary cummins, mahershala ali,  
I just saw "Green Book" win the best movie Oscar. Aside from the fact that I don't think it should have won for cinematographic reasons, it should not have won because it's based on a fraud and lies. The movie does not depict what actually happened or the true relationship between Tony Vallelonga and Don Shirley.

August 17, 2018 I heard they were coming out with a movie based on Donald Shirley's life. It looked interesting so I researched Don Shirley. I saw that he died. I checked findagrave.com to see if anyone had made his memorial. They hadn't so I set upon doing research about Don Shirley, his life, his relatives, his family. That night I put up his memorial and added the memorials of his dead relatives. I added their obituaries so you could clearly see their surviving relatives. Below is the memorial I created August 17, 2018. I included public obituaries from two major media sources. The obituaries showing his living relatives were publicly available since he died in 2013. One search and you would have seen Maurice, Edwina and Edwin Shirley III. One Google and you get two email addresses and home addresses.

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/192336646/donald-walbridge-shirley

Any Google search would have pulled up all of his dead and living relatives easily. Mahershala Ali, Nick Vallelonga did not try to contact the relatives intentionally. Nick knew that Don Shirley told Tony he did NOT give him permission to write a book or make a movie about their time together. Nick has been in the movie industry since 1972. He clearly looked upon this as a business opportunity. The relatives also stated that Don Shirley was not a close friend of Tony Vallelonga. I don't know if Tony lied to his family or they knew this and decided to change the story line to make their deceased father look like some sort of civil rights hero?

Below is the tree I made August 17, 2018. They could have found it on Ancestry with one search. I've since made it private. Below is the pedigree view of Don Shirley's tree. I posted the full tree at geneanet.org

green book, screen play, dr donald shirley, movie, oscar, award, best picture, fraud, nick vallelonga, tony vallelonga, fiction, fraud, lies, mary cummins, mahershala ali, 


Below is the normal view of his tree. All those people on the bottom are alive. Don Shirley had many close relatives. He had no children of his own but he was very close with his brothers, nieces, nephews. Nick Vallelonga did not contact his relatives because he knew they would say no as Don had said no. The relatives most certainly would not want this fake narrative made into a movie.

green book, screen play, dr donald shirley, movie, oscar, award, best picture, fraud, nick vallelonga, tony vallelonga, fiction, fraud, lies, mary cummins, mahershala ali, 

From Wikipedia:

"Shirley family reaction

Shirley's relatives condemned the film, stating they were not contacted by studio representatives until after development, and that it misrepresented Shirley's relationship with his family. Don's brother, Maurice Shirley, said "My brother never considered Tony to be his 'friend'; he was an employee, his chauffeur (who resented wearing a uniform and cap). This is why context and nuance are so important. The fact that a successful, well-to-do Black artist would employ domestics that did NOT look like him, should not be lost in translation."

More from Maurice Shirley and his nephew Edwin Shirley III.

https://shadowandact.com/the-real-donald-shirley-green-book-hollywood-swallowed-whole

Mahershala Ali responded with an apology to Shirley’s nephew, Edwin Shirley III, saying that "I did the best I could with the material I had" and that he was not aware that there were "close relatives with whom I could have consulted to add some nuance to the character." Writer-director Peter Farrelly said he was under the impression there "weren't a lot of family members" still alive, that they did not take major liberties with the story, and that relatives he was aware of had been invited to a private screening for friends and family.

Look at who is behind the film, a bunch of white guys. A bunch of white guys happy to use famous and well respected Dr Donald Shirley as a character to create a false narrative that makes a white guy appear to be a civil rights "hero."


In the below pic for best picture the only two black people are actors. Looks like white people taking advantage of a well known black person for money and fame. They could have at least hired black people besides just some actors. 


Mary Cummins of Animal Advocates is a wildlife rehabilitator licensed by the California Department of Fish and Game. Mary Cummins is also a licensed real estate appraiser in Los Angeles, California.

Mary Cummins, Mary K. Cummins, Mary Katherine Cummins, Mary Cummins-Cobb, Mary, Cummins, Cobb, real estate, appraiser, appraisal, instructor, teacher, Los Angeles, Santa Monica, Beverly Hills, Pasadena, Brentwood, Bel Air, California, licensed, permitted, single family, condo, pud, hud, fannie mae, freddie mac, uspap, certified, residential, certified resident, apartment building, multi-family, commercial, industrial, expert witness, civil, criminal, orea, dre, insurance, bonded, experienced, bilingual, spanish, english, form, 1004, 2055, land, raw, acreage, vacant, insurance, cost, income approach, market analysis, comparative, theory, appraisal theory, cost approach, sales, matched pairs, plot, plat, map, diagram, photo, photographs, photography, rear, front, street, subject, comparable, sold, listed, active, pending, expired, cancelled, listing, mls, multiple listing service, claw, themls,

Take 3 Film Festival at Plaza de Cultural y Artes by Mary Cummins, Maria Rivera

Take 3 Film Festival presented by East LA Film Festival , Panamanian International Film Festival/LA and La Plaza de Cultura y Artes was hel...